Military spending puts
[PoliticsWatch posted 5:15 p.m. June 27, 2006]
This week is defence week for the federal government.
Defence Minister Gordon O'Connor is expected to make a major
military spending announcement every day for this week at various
military installations across the country.
When the week is over, the federal government is expected to
announce $15 billion in spending on ships, helicopters, trucks and
O'Connor's tour began on Monday with a stop in Halifax where he
announced plans to purchase three new joint support ships for $2.1
However, what is supposed to be a good news week for the government,
as the defence minister crosses the country and tells the troops
first hand about the new purchases will benefit them, got off to a
The first question O'Connor faced from a reporter after making the
announcement in Halifax was about his former career as a defence
Before entering government O'Connor spent nearly eight years as a
registered lobbyist at the firm Hill and Knowlton. The lobbyist
registry shows that during his time as a lobbyist O'Connor had a
list of clients that included a who's who of the global defence
The minister was asked Monday if he had "ever received any
money or done any work with any of the companies involved in the
four consortiums bidding for this contract."
O'Connor said he "helped" General Dynamics on an
artillery project "years ago."
When asked if he had disclosed this, the minister became visibly
"I have disclosed everything. If you want to keep chasing this
I can," he said.
"I have disclosed everything. I own no shares in any company. I
get no renumeration from any company. I have no connections with any
company. I have been through the ethics counsellor. I have no
recusals. There is nothing there at all.
"I know the opposition continues to try to chase this, but
there's nothing there."
Indeed, the opposition has chased this, with little traction.
Since the new Parliament opened in April, the Liberals have asked 19
questions about O'Connor's past lobbying.
Recently, O'Connor drew weary of the repeated questions from Liberal
defence critic Ujjal Dosanjh and responded by saying, "Mr. Speaker, the
Hon. member is locked in Groundhog Day. The member keeps asking the same question and he gets the same answer. The same answer is, I have followed the rules in the past, I will follow the rules now and I will follow the rules in the future."
The Liberals have increased their attacks on O'Connor within the
last week after Radio Canada broke the news of the $15 billion in
new defence spending.
Dosanjh and Liberal MP Denis Coderre held a press conference
where they listed the five purchases and the links to O'Connor's
According to the Liberals, for the $2.1 billion Joint Support Ships
project announced Monday, three of the firms involved were once
clients of O'Connor's -- BAE Systems, Raytheon Canada and
The $1.1 billion for the Medium Logistic Trucks involves Stewart-Stevenson,
a firm O'Connor was once registered to lobby for.
Another procurement expected to be announced this week is for
tactical airlift. O'Connor once lobbied for Airbus, which is now
known as EADS and is a potential bidder.
Last November, the Liberal government announced
plans to go ahead with procurement on the tactical airlift, but
many believed the time of delivery specifications for the
procurement would have shut out EADS.
Boeing has C-17s in production whereas EADS's A400Ms are not yet
being made but will be in production in late 2008 or 2009.
Then defence minister Bill Graham at the time denied any firm
was being shut out
"We need an aircraft that can do certain things and (Chief of
Defence Staff Gen. Rick Hillier) defined them and they will be defined in the performance requirements and we need it by a certain time, not there, but within a certain time
limit," Graham said.
If EADS gets back into the bidding under the new procurement it will
certainly raise eyebrows in Ottawa.
After Tuesday's announcement, the Liberals renewed their attacks on
O'Connor and called for him to recuse himself from the process or
resign as defence minister.
"Nearly all of these purchases will either be awarded to, or bid on by, companies that the
minister was once paid to represent, making the appearance of many potential conflicts quite
clear," Coderre said in a statement.
Coderre added that O'Connor's continued involvement could create
delays and lawsuits against the government from losing
Losing companies could challenge the government's decision to pick a
winner before the Canadian International Trade Tribunal. While that
is a possibility it is one that is unlikely to be successful.
The House of Commons recently passed the Federal Accountability Act,
which imposes restrictions on the lobbying industry at the federal
The Act includes a five-year ban on lobbying for former cabinet
ministers, ministerial staff and senior public servants, effectively
preventing politicians from becoming lobbyists.
But there is nothing in the Act or existing
rules that would prevent a lobbyist from becoming a
Duff Conacher of the the public interest group Democracy
Watch says that while O'Connor is not breaking any rules, the prime
minister broke the "spirit" of the code of conduct for
public office holders in picking O'Connor as defence minister.
He specifically cites one of the principles of the code that says
public office holders should uphold the highest ethical standard so that public confidence and trust in the integrity, objectivity and impartiality in government are conserved and
"He was seven years a lobbyist," said Conacher. " That's a long time, a lot of relations you build and when he was appointed he was less than two years removed from that."
Conacher also blames Ethics Commissioner Bernard Shapiro for
not having O'Connor recuse himself on some files and said this kind
of thing would not happen if the ethics rules in Ottawa were
"For a government that has spoken so much about integrity and accountability and the connection between the lobbying industry and ministers and lobbyists and ministers, having him as minister is not
consistent with the conservatives' message," Conacher added.
Despite all the conflict of interest
allegations being levelled at the minister from the opposition,
Prime Minister Stephen Harper has remained fully supportive
of O'Connor, who is also a former Brigadier General.
"The fact of the matter is the minister has experience," Harper
told CBC Newsworld last week when asked about O'Connor and the
"He has the full support of National Defence in what he's doing. The full support of the cabinet. And I think ultimately the process he will be announcing is one that's transparent and open, will deliver value for the taxpayers, will deliver military needs promptly and will also give the military
what they actually need."
© PoliticsWatch® 2006. All rights reserved. Republication
or redistribution of PoliticsWatch content, including by framing,
copying, linking or similar means, is expressly prohibited without
the prior written consent of Public Interests Research and Communications
Inc. (PIRCINC). PoliticsWatch is registered trademark of PIRCINC.