Jewish groups condemn Green Party
leader's Nazi comments
[PoliticsWatch updated 5:00 p.m. May 1, 2007]
Two of the country's leading Jewish human rights groups are
condemning Green Party leader Elizabeth May's comments comparing
Prime Minister Stephen Harper's handling of the climate change issue
to pre Second World War Nazi appeasement.
Over the weekend, May delivered a sermon to a congregation in
Southern Ontario in which she said Harper and his
Conservative government's handling of the climate change issue was
worse than former British prime minister Neville Chamberlain's
appeasement of Nazi Germany shortly before the Second World War and
the ensuing Holocaust.
May also attacked U.S. President George W. Bush and said that
he was part of a group of evangelical Christians that welcomed an
"They are waiting for the end time in glee and they unfortunately include (U.S.) President (George W.)
Bush," the London Free Press quoted her as saying.
May stood by her comments in an interview with the Ottawa Citizen
that was published on Tuesday.
Since then both the Canadian Jewish Congress and B'nai
Brith Canada have written letters or issued statements
expressing shock at the Green Party leader's statements.
"The Nazi analogy shows May's insensitivity to context and
history," Ed Morgan, president of the Canadian Jewish
Congress, wrote in a letter that he sent to the PMO
"Her comparison of Stephen Harper to Neville Chamberlain is both demagogic and
inappropriate, revealing that the Green Party leader is still too green to
have learned to control her excesses of rhetoric."
Frank Dimant, executive vice President of B'nai Brith
Canada, said in a statement that he has written to May to express
concern over the comments.
"The evoking of the Nazi era by the Green Party leader in order to score political points is insensitive to those who lived through this dark time,"
May's comments also came to the floor of the House of Commons during
question period where the prime minister attempted to tar Liberal
Leader Stephane Dion with May's controversy.
Dion and May recently announced a non-aggression pact in which the
Liberals will not field a candidate in the Central Nova riding where
May is running in the next election.
The deal has been criticized privately by numerous Liberal MPs and
officials who question Dion's judgement in making a deal with a
party that has no seats in the House of Commons.
Harper read excerpts from Morgan's letter and urged Dion on
three separate occasions to distance himself from the Green
"The Leader of the Opposition hitched his wagon to this
individual," the PM said. "I hope he will distance himself from those kinds of remarks."
Dion never addressed the issue in the House and Liberal MP Michael
Ignatieff accused the prime minister of trying to change the
channel from the ongoing detainee controversy the Liberals have been
focusing on in question period for over week.
After question period, Dion, who himself has often referred to
Harper as a "climate-change denier," told reporters
that May should withdraw the comments regarding Nazi appeasement.
He said he "understands" both why the groups are upset and
what May was trying to do, noting that academics and authors often
use the Chamberlain comparison when discussing inaction on issues
such as poverty and the environment.
"We should not use it because for the very reason that in the spectrum of horror the Nazi regime is beyond any
comparison," he said.
Dion said he was not aware of May's other comments about evangelical
Christians and President Bush. He also defended his deal with May
when reporters asked him if it is creating unexpected headaches and
Liberal environment critic David McGuinty called May's
comments "over the top" and "unacceptable."
"I think she should apologize," he said.
McGuinty also put a large amount of distance between his party and
May and said the Liberal party should not have to be held
responsible for what May says.
Even though Dion has said May should be in Parliament, McGuinty
denied that Dion has ever endorsed May.
"We didn't endorse the candidate," he said. "We said
that we are going to facilitate the potential entrance of a new
leader of the Green Party in the House of Commons. It's in keeping
with a Parliamentary tradition."
"We don't take responsibility for everything Elizabeth May says
no more than she should take responsibility for everything my leader
says," he added.
© PoliticsWatch® 2007. All rights reserved. Republication
or redistribution of PoliticsWatch content, including by framing,
copying, linking or similar means, is expressly prohibited without
the prior written consent of Public Interests Research and Communications
Inc. (PIRCINC). PoliticsWatch is registered trademark of PIRCINC.