Calls for Defence Minister's
[PoliticsWatch updated 5:00 p.m. April 30, 2007]
|Defence Minister Gordon O'Connor.
Canada's Defence Minister was not in the House of Commons Monday,
but that did not stop opposition MPs from continuing to call for his
resignation amidst a controversy surrounding the handling of Afghan
Defence Minister Gordon O'Connor has not commented
publicly on the controversy involving allegations of abuse by 30
former Afghan detainees interviewed by the Globe and Mail since his
appearance before the Commons foreign affairs committee last
The detainees told the Globe that they suffered various forms of
torture after Canadian troops handed them over to Afghan officials.
No Canadian troops are accused of mistreating the detainees while in
On Thursday, O'Connor, a former general, sat in his seat in the
House of Commons during the entire question period as other cabinet
ministers and parliamentary secretaries took the heat instead. But
on Monday, O'Connor was absent from question period.
"It's obvious that everybody has lost confidence in the minister of defence who is responsible for this mess in the first
place," Liberal Leader Stephane Dion said. "Does the prime minister still have confidence in his minister of
Once again Prime Minister Stephen Harper did not directly
answer the question.
Instead, the prime minister attacked the Liberals and said there was
"no evidence" of the specific allegations contained the
"The bottom line is unlike the members opposite we don't
automatically assume that any allegations made by the Taliban
against Canadian forces are the unvarnished truth," Harper
Liberal MP Michael Ignatieff said Harper's response
"makes it clear that the prime minister agrees with the
Official Opposition that the defence minister is no longer capable
of doing his job."
Since O'Connor's appearance before the foreign affairs committee
last week, speculation about his ouster from cabinet has replaced
election speculation as the new past time on Parliament Hill.
A Conservative source told the Globe and Mail last week that the government is not pleased with the
defence minister's numerous missteps, but that canning him would raise questions about the
Afghanistan mission and Canada's resolve in
Opposition MPs believe that Harper has indeed lost confidence in his
minister and is simply waiting until Parliament recesses for the
summer in early June to shuffle him out.
Ignatieff suggested in the House that such timing would be
"NATO is going to be starting a new offensive, insurgents are attacking our soldiers and the prime minister is looking for the right time to get rid of his
minister," he said. "Why doesn't the prime minister put our soldiers ahead of his own interests? Why doesn't he fire his
incompetent minister immediately?"
After 15 months in power, the Conservative government has yet to
have a minister resign because of pressure from the opposition
One cabinet minister, former intergovernmental affairs minister Michael
Chong, stepped down last fall because he could not support the
government's motion recognizing the Quebecois as a nation. Other
ministers under fire, such as former environment minister Rona
Ambrose, were shuffled around but remained in cabinet.
Harper, who has a reputation in Ottawa for not backing down,
withstood months of pressure from opposition MPs calling for Ambrose
to resign before making a cabinet shuffle.
However, the uproar over the torture allegations have become the
centre of attention on Parliament Hill for over a week now, even
taking away some of the spotlight from the government's
long-anticipated announcement of greenhouse gas targets.
And the opposition parties, especially the Liberals, do not appear
like they will let up in calling for O'Connor to be
"We believe that Mr. O'Connor should be asked to resign his position," NDP Leader
Jack Layton said after question period.
"I think with the last two days with virtually no response on his part, the last two days in the House, indicates that perhaps even the
prime minister has lost confidence in him."
Liberal defence critic Denis Coderre said the prime minister
is "in denial" and does not want to admit that the
opposition parties were right about the seriousness of the issue of
"He's waiting for the occasion to make his political move when
we need that move now," he said of getting rid of the minister.
"He's going to play games like that. He likes to play tactics
and games and right now the department needs a minister of
© PoliticsWatch® 2007. All rights reserved. Republication
or redistribution of PoliticsWatch content, including by framing,
copying, linking or similar means, is expressly prohibited without
the prior written consent of Public Interests Research and Communications
Inc. (PIRCINC). PoliticsWatch is registered trademark of PIRCINC.