Baird won't comment on oil
[PoliticsWatch updated 4:10 p.m., February 8, 2007]
|Environment Minister John Baird.
OTTAWA — Environment
Minister John Baird offered no comment on a contentious tax
incentive for Canada's oil sands while appearing before a Commons
committee on Thursday.
Pressure has been growing in recent weeks on the government
to end the accelerated capital cost allowance, which allows oil companies
to write off all of the capital expenses they incur before they start paying income taxes.
NDP Leader Jack Layton has said he wants the government to stop providing
the tax write-offs in exchange for NDP support of the
government's Clean Air Act.
During Baird's appearance before the special Commons committee on
the Clean Air Act on Thursday, NDP MP Nathan Cullen asked
Baird if he would "end the perverse subsidies to the tar sands."
Baird responded by saying, "With respect to taxation of the oil industry that will be another issue for
(Finance Minister Jim) Flaherty to speak to."
Baird's lack of a ringing endorsement of the current policy will no
doubt continue to rattle the nerves of Canada's oil industry.
On Thursday morning, the Globe and Mail reported it obtained a copy
of a letter to Indian Affairs Minister Jim Prentice from the
chair of the Canadian Association of Petroleum Producers in which
the association defends the accelerated write off.
Prentice is the chair of a special cabinet committee dealing with
the implementation of the Clean Air Act.
Baird, Prentice and Natural Resources Minister Gary Lunn are
scheduled to meet with oil executives in Calgary on Friday.
The letter is being viewed in Ottawa as a sign that the industry is
concerned the minority government will bow to political pressure and
end the tax break.
"Now that I've seen the oil executives start to show up in the
media claiming that there are no tax breaks and they aren't
subsidized, that gives me cause to believe that they're actually
starting to realize that this thing could be gone," Cullen told
reporters after the committee meeting.
"The gravy train is over and Canadian taxpayers are not going
to subsidize them any more."
In question period, Bloc Quebecois Leader Gilles Duceppe
pressed Prime Minister Stephen Harper on the
"Given the tax breaks that are given to the oil companies and
given the fact that they represent some $3 billion and will reach an
even greater amount ... shouldn't that money not be used for
combating global warming?"
Harper made no commitment on the tax breaks, but noted that the
sector was already affected by his government's decision last year
not to tax income trusts.
The Bloc is leading an effort on the Commons finance committee to
have oil sands executives to appear to testify about the tax
"We want (an) explanation," Duceppe said. "It's a lot
of money -- $3 billion between 2005 and 2008."
© PoliticsWatch® 2007. All rights reserved. Republication
or redistribution of PoliticsWatch content, including by framing,
copying, linking or similar means, is expressly prohibited without
the prior written consent of Public Interests Research and Communications
Inc. (PIRCINC). PoliticsWatch is registered trademark of PIRCINC.