Parliament will revisit same-sex
marriage this fall: PM
[PoliticsWatch posted 5:55 p.m. June 2, 2006]
The issue of gay marriage is back on the national
Prime Minister Stephen Harper effectively reopened the debate
on Friday when he told reporters in Montreal that the House of
Commons will hold a free vote on a motion this fall on whether to
revisit the issue.
"A vote will be in the fall," Harper said. "It will be a free vote. We committed to that in our platform."
In its election platform, the Conservatives committed to "hold a truly free vote on the definition of marriage in the next session of Parliament. If the resolution
is passed, the government will introduce legislation to restore the traditional definition of marriage while
respecting existing same-sex marriages."
Last summer, the Senate gave Royal Assent to Bill C-38, which was
the Martin government's same-sex marriage legislation.
That vote appeared to bring to an end a divisive debate in federal
politics that had been going on for more than two years after an
Ontario Court of Appeal ruling in favour of same-sex
Former prime minister Paul Martin made the vote free for his backbench MPs, but not for his cabinet ministers. Many of those cabinet ministers had voted for the traditional definition of marriage in previous votes in the House of Commons.
This included key Martin allies, such as Joe Volpe and Tony
Valeri, who reversed their position once in cabinet.
One cabinet minister, Joe Comuzzi, resigned from cabinet shortly before the vote because it would have violated an election promise he made to constituents.
Harper is promising a free vote for all MPs and says he will not
whip his cabinet.
Martin met with reporters on Friday to discuss his private member's
bill on the Kelowna accord, but he responded to PoliticsWatch's
question about his response to the PM's announcement earlier in the
"This is a Charter question and a very important Charter question,"
the former PM said. "I think that if this happens, what the government would be attempting to be putting in place is in fact a series of measures which could conceivably lead to the use of the notwithstanding clause. And my position is very clear that the notwithstanding clause should not be used and in fact that the legislation that we brought in in terms of same-sex marriage should stand."
Martin went on to say that he does not understand the positions the
Conservatives are taking on a range of issues, including marriage,
the Kelowna Accord and child care.
"These were major steps forward and I believe in fact that what the government ought to be doing is building on the foundations of previous governments as opposed to essentially trying to tear down the foundations that have been
built," he added.
Harper's comments come just two days after a number of Conservative
MPs told the Canadian Press they were not anxious to reopen the gay
This included several who voted against Bill C-38 just last
"Personally, I have mixed feelings on that ..." Tory MP James
Rajotte told CP this week.
"I recognize that same-sex marriage has been the law in Canada for some time now, and I also recognize the difficulty in reversing it to the point where traditional marriage is the only legal union in Canada," he said.
"For that reason I would say I'm undecided about it, but I'm thinking seriously about it now."
In the last gay marriage vote in the House, four Tory MPs voted with
the government in support of the government's legislation -- Belinda
Stronach, James Moore, Jim Prentice and Gerald
Stronach is now with the Liberals, but the other three were
In addition, the Tory caucus has a number of new MPs who are also in
favour of gay marriage, including Tory MP Garth Turner, who
has become embroiled in a war of words with Defend Marriage,
a group in favour of the traditional definition of marriage that is
considering targeting the next riding nominations of Tories on the
other side of the debate.
"When one religious or cultural group engineers a coup, overwhelming existing political party members and workers, and replacing a politician elected by a plurality of people with a single-issue monochromatic militant, well, kiss democracy
goodbye," Turner wrote on his blog
on May 26.
"Call it Defend Marriage Canada. Call it the Taliban."
There was much confusion earlier this year when the government
introduced its throne speech but did not mention revisiting gay
The pro-gay marriage group Canadians for Equal Marriage was so puzzled by the omission that it held a press conference to ask Harper to clear up whether he planned to go ahead with the vote.
"Mr. Harper is obviously laying low on re-opening equal marriage," Laurie
Arron, national coordinator for the group, said in April.
But groups in favour of the traditional definition of marriage told
PoliticsWatch at the time that they were confident Harper would live
up to his election commitment.
The vote will likely be close, but groups who support gay marriages
said they are confident they have the numbers to defeat a motion to
reopen the marriage law.
© PoliticsWatch® 2006. All rights reserved. Republication
or redistribution of PoliticsWatch content, including by framing,
copying, linking or similar means, is expressly prohibited without
the prior written consent of Public Interests Research and Communications
Inc. (PIRCINC). PoliticsWatch is registered trademark of PIRCINC.