::  


SECTION 3

3.1 Overview
3.2 Study Components
3.3 Methodology
3.4 National / political front pages
3.5 Lead story pages
3.6 Site profiles
3.7 Top line results


Submitted by:
A.M. Burton

Submitted to:
School of Journalism and Communication, Carleton University (Ottawa, Canada),

in part completion of the requirements for the

Master of Journalism

September 2000

:: Research Base

SECTION 3

ONLINE POLITICAL NEWS CONVERAGE
A STUDY OF FIRST BALLOT VOTING IN THE CANADIAN ALLIANCE LEADERSHIP RACE (JUNE 22 - 24, 2000)

3.5  Lead Stories

Story Source

Lead stories originating with the hosting news organization accounted for 43.1 per cent of lead stories.

Predictably, Web sites hosted by traditional media outlets generally featured double-duty content, that is, content written by the same journalists who contribute to the newspaper. TheStar.ca and TheGlobeandMail.com featured original content lead stories in every download.

CBC.ca also featured exclusively original content. However, given that journalists were not accorded bylines, it is unlikely that the same journalists produced the Web site content as produce the television and radio content, the way in which newspaper journalists feed both the print and online editions.

By contrast, lead stories on Internet portal Web sites overwhelmingly featured Canadian Press wire copy. Overall, Canadian Press wire service copy was the source for 33.6 per cent of lead stories. In an apparently similar business arrangement, aol.ca featured exclusively CBC Web copy as its news content.

Finally, as discussed in the previous section, Yahoo.ca was unique among the study sites in offering comprehensive 'meta-journalism': that is, a collection of links to stories from across media including audio, video, wire and print sources. As a result, the source of the lead story varied from download to download.

The Bourque Newswatch site is also modeled on a meta-journalistic concept. However, the lead story often was a one paragraph piece of original content.

Byline

One of the more troubling findings of this study, at least from the perspective of journalists, was that byline credit was far from assured on news Web sites. As mentioned above, CBC.ca never accorded any credit to a journalist for writing posted news articles. By extension, aol.ca did not either. This may be because CBC.ca Web content is produced by what amounts to a rewrite desk.

Equally troubling, Excite.ca actually stripped the name of the journalist from wire stories, resulting in the Canadian Press journalist being given byline credit on all Web sites featuring Canadian Press wire copy except Excite.ca.

As the traditional media move onto the Web, it appears they may also place less emphasis on crediting journalists for their work. While a journalist was credited in each lead story on the more static sites, TheStar.ca and NationalPost.com, on the more dynamic TheGlobeandMail.com site no journalist was credited with a byline in two of 12 downloads.

Lead Changes

Only those sites with journalists filing copy in 'real time' appeared to treat lead stories as 'living documents'. CBC.ca and TheGlobeandMail.com were the only sites where in some instances lead stories remained more or less the same between downloads but the lead paragraph of the story was edited or updated by the journalist.

Generally, however, the lead either remained exactly the same in the previous download or had a completely new lead story posted.

In 54.9 per cent of downloaded lead stories the lead (and by extension the lead story) had not changed; in 39.8 per cent of downloads the story was completely new. The likelihood of there being a completely new lead story posted at a given Web site was correlated with the time of the download and not correlated with which Web site it was posted on.

Interactivity

As with the political front pages, the lead stories were somewhat disappointing in terms of integrating the unique interactive features of the Internet such as audience polls, quizzes and discussion forums into lead story pages. In 61.1 per cent of lead stories there were no interactive features whatsoever.

Those sites that did integrate interactive features into lead story pages were not necessarily the same sites that did so on the national / political news front pages. For example, TheStar.ca, which had no interactive features on the front page, featured a 'speak out' discussion forum link at the end of each story page, as did Canoe.com and Sympatico.ca.

Photographs

No photographs appeared on 52.2 per cent of lead story pages. TheGlobeandMail.com, Excite.ca and Bourque Newswatch did not include a photograph in any of the lead stories downloaded for this study.

In 20.4 per cent of lead stories there was one photograph. Sympatico.ca was most consistent, including a photograph on nine out of 12 lead story pages.

Lead story pages featured four or more photographs in 16.8 per cent of downloads. CBC.ca and aol.ca featured four or more photographs in six out of 12 downloaded stories. Yahoo.ca and TheStar.ca included four or more photographs in 33.3 per cent and 25.0 per cent of downloads, respectively.

Audio and Video

Again, as on the national / political front pages, links to audio or video were rare on most sites. In total there were no such links in 73.5 per cent of downloaded lead stories.

NationalPost.com, TheGlobeandMail.com, TheStar.ca, Canoe.com, Excite.ca, Sympatico.ca and Bourque Newswatch did not feature any audio or video links in any downloaded lead story.

Given their origination with a broadcast media source, it is not surprising that CBC.ca and aol.ca most consistently featured audio and video links on lead story pages. There were at least three audio or video links in each downloaded lead story from these two (essentially identical) Web sites.

Yahoo.ca featured four or more audio or video links in six out of nine downloaded lead stories.

Links to Other News

The number of links to related leadership news stories included on each lead story page varied from site to site, and between downloads.

Many lead story pages, 31.9 per cent of all downloads, included five or more links to related news.

However, 39.8 per cent of lead story pages had no links to related news stories at all.

Links to Party and Candidate Sites

Links to related Web sites were much more rare. This suggests that Web site hosts may prefer to keep online news users within their site to read their news rather than encourage site users to explore a broader spectrum of information sources.

Many sites, 60.2 per cent in all - including TheStar.ca, Canoe.com, Excite.ca, Sympatico.ca and the Bourque Newswatch site - did not include any links to party or candidate sites at all. A further 27.4 per cent of downloaded lead story pages featured just one link, generally to the Canadian Alliance home page.

Links to Policy Sites

Links to policy sites were even more rare. Only 0.9 per cent of downloaded lead story pages had more than one link to a policy-oriented site.

Generally, lead story pages did not have any links to policy related sites. This was the case 73.5 per cent of the time. There was one link to a policy oriented site in 25.7 per cent of downloaded lead stories.

 next section

Research Base
Go direct:

Table of Contents

Section 1


Section 2


Section 3
Politics Watch Study

Section 4
Conclusion

Section 5



 

PoliticsWatch Home  |  News Services  Voter Resources  |  Research Base

© PoliticsWatch® 2004. All rights reserved. Republication or redistribution of PoliticsWatch content, 
including by framing, copying, linking or similar means, is expressly prohibited without the prior written consent of 
Public Interests Research and Communications Inc. (PIRCINC). PoliticsWatch is registered trademark of PIRCINC.
PoliticsWatch® | Canada's Political Portal™
85 Albert Street, Suite 1502, Ottawa ON K1P 6A4 |  phone: 613.232.0516
news@politicswatch.com  |  Terms of Service, Copyright, Trademarks, and Disclaimers Statement