Opposition accuses Tories of more
[PoliticsWatch updated 5:20 p.m., February 5, 2007]
|Prime Minister Stephen Harper.
OTTAWA — The
federal Conservative government came under fire on Monday after reports on the weekend that
two more election campaign promises appear like they will be broken.
The Tory election promise to work with the provinces to
develop a patient wait times guarantee, one of the Tories' five
priorities, will not be delivered before the next election, Health
Minister Tony Clement said in an interview on the
And Prime Minister Stephen Harper's promise to beef up Arctic
sovereignty by building a deep water port in Canada's North and
creating a fleet of armed ice breakers is not included in a copy of
the federal government's first defence strategy paper that was leaked to
The Tories are still being criticized in the House and behind the
scenes for the October reversal of another promise to not tax income
trusts. A Commons committee held a week of hearings last week to
examine that issue.
Both the prime minister and Clement came under fire in the House
during question period on Monday for the wait times guarantee
promise apparently being broken.
"We know the prime minister breaks his promises," said NDP Leader Jack Layton. "We've seen it on lobbyists, we've seen it on appointments, we've seen it on income trusts. But I think
(Canadians) expected better when it comes to something as important as health wait times."
"Why won't the prime minister honour his word to Canadians on health care?"
Harper responded by describing the issue of wait times as "a long-term objective"
and said the Tories "didn't promise a quick fix for a generation."
"We are making a serious long term effort and we will have
results," Harper said.
Both Harper and Clement pointed to the findings of a study released
Monday by the Canadian Institute for Health Information that
found 42,000 additional procedures in wait time priority areas were performed in Canada outside Quebec in 2005–2006 compared to the previous year.
"These are the facts," Clement said of the study in the
House. "We are meeting our wait time targets."
However Jennifer Zelmer, CIHI’s Vice-President, Research and
Analysis, noted in the report that while the number of surgeries in
priority areas have increased "it’s not clear what impact this is having on actual wait times for Canadians, because we do not yet have comparable data to track trends in how long patients across the country waited for surgery."
After question period, when asked by PoliticsWatch about CIHI's
caveat about its findings, Clement said "I think for those
42,000 people that got that surgery earlier that's good news for
"But does more have to be done? Absolutely it does and we're
not going to rest until more is done."
The Liberals also criticized what they called the government's
"broken promise" on the deep water port for the
"Several communities are now actively lobbying and preparing construction for this deep water
port," said Liberal northern affairs critic Larry Bagnell, who represents the
"Leaked documents suggest the Conservatives will now only build a refueling site for naval ships and the construction of six small Arctic patrol vessels that cannot even go in the ice.
This is a far cry from an Arctic deep sea port and a fleet of icebreakers."
Defence Minister Gordon O'Connor, however, discredited the
CanWest leaked document and said "this is a case where Canadians cannot always believe what they read.
The government will meet its commitments."
NDP MP Dennis Bevington, who represents the Western Arctic
riding, said in an interview with PoliticsWatch, that the NDP never
"bought into" the ice breaker project and did not view the
deep water port as something that should be a military
"We think we need to spend money on the North on Arctic
sovereignty," he noted, but said the preference was through
advance research and not a focus on defence.
"If it's simply for defence purposes that you're creating a
deep water port than there are probably better ways to ensure
Northern sovereignty than going through these large capital
Bevington said the Tories' promise for the North was primarily
"retail politics" that "doesn't work out so
well" when the policy has to be implemented.
© PoliticsWatch® 2007. All rights reserved. Republication
or redistribution of PoliticsWatch content, including by framing,
copying, linking or similar means, is expressly prohibited without
the prior written consent of Public Interests Research and Communications
Inc. (PIRCINC). PoliticsWatch is registered trademark of PIRCINC.