Civil servants under investigation
for working in ministerial offices
[PoliticsWatch updated 1:25 p.m. March 29, 2007]
The circumstances surrounding the hiring of 97 public servants who
had worked in ministers offices dating back to 1990 is being
examined Public Service Commissioner Maria Barrados.
Last month Barrados announced the scope of her investigation
will include 97 public servants dating back to 1990.
The investigation is putting a spotlight on public servants who take
a leave of absence to work in a minister's office and then return to
the public service.
Barrados is conducting the probe and making it a priority because of
the interest of MPs and the government following her discovery last
fall that two former Liberal aides landed what she alleged were "phantom
jobs" in two separate federal departments.
The aides, who Barrados cannot name for privacy reasons, were former public servants who were at the time on unpaid
leave to work in the offices of two Liberal cabinet ministers.
Their old public service jobs had been filled and Barrados said the
two aides were "part of those discussions" in getting Health Canada and
Public Works and Government Services Canada to create new positions for them to later
be filled under a
special assignment program for bureaucrats.
The two positions allowed the aides to skip the priority system,
which is the traditional route most public servants take to return
to the bureaucracy, according to Barrados.
"They had used their position in ministers' offices to have these positions created for them and maintained for
them," Barrados said in a recent interview with PoliticsWatch.
"Then when their time was up in exempt staff, they came directly into a department guaranteed job and salary, everything there waiting for them. For us that was entirely inappropriate."
Barrados said she refers to the positions as phantom jobs because
the two aides "were never assigned anything. They weren't there. They never held them, but they were just sort of like a holding spot for them."
Upon discovering the incident Barrados revoked the two
After the release of her annual report in October of last year, then
Treasury Board President John Baird seized upon Barrados'
discovery of another controversy involving the Liberals and the
culture of entitlement.
The Conservatives campaigned in the last election on the issue of accountability and
But Barrados later told the Commons Government Operations committee
that it wasn't as simple as a couple of Liberals staffers creating
jobs for themselves, but in fact was approved by the deputy
ministers in each department.
"It's the department that has to create the position, so obviously people in human resources would have some knowledge, and it's the deputy minister who had to approve
these," Barrados told the committee.
David Marshall is the current deputy minister of Public Works
and Government Services Canada and Morris Rosenberg is the
current deputy minister Health Canada.
The two departments also stood by their
decision to create the special assignments for the two aides at the
time, according to Barrados.
Barrados told PoliticsWatch that despite the deputy ministers'
originally approving the jobs they have not challenged her
"Nobody challenged me in the way that you can challenge me. You can take me to court. Nobody did any of that. So I assume that without any real challenge we may have a difference of opinion of the moment, but nobody has really challenged what our conclusion was."
Health Canada said in an email response to PoliticsWatch that the
deputy minister has
no plans to appeal or challenge Barrados' decision.
"The Department has already complied with the corrective actions and therefore has no further
comment," Health Canada said.
Public Works could not respond to PoliticsWatch's request
for an update.
Barados told PoliticsWatch that she can't give a breakdown at the
moment of how many of the 97 public servants being scrutinized
worked in the offices of Liberal or Conservative cabinet
ministers. However, the scope of her investigation goes far
back enough to include civil servants who worked in ministers'
offices in the governments of Brian Mulroney and Kim
Campbell in the early 1990s. Many of these officials are now in
senior ranks of the public service.
She is also excluding clerical and administrative staff from her
probe, saying there is "less risk" for people in those
jobs to be "non-partisan."
"If you're doing office support work that work would not be very different whether you're working for a minister or whether you're working for a government manager nor would you likely be questioned about the integrity and the ability to do the work given that you might have worked in a minister's
office," she said.
Barrados said she is a proponent of public servants gaining
experience and insight working in ministers' offices "but I think it's the kind of movement that we need to monitor and I think we should have a few rules of the road around it."
© PoliticsWatch® 2007. All rights reserved. Republication
or redistribution of PoliticsWatch content, including by framing,
copying, linking or similar means, is expressly prohibited without
the prior written consent of Public Interests Research and Communications
Inc. (PIRCINC). PoliticsWatch is registered trademark of PIRCINC.