|
Industry can't veto softwood deal:
Emerson
by Romeo St. Martin
[PoliticsWatch posted 6:30 p.m. July 13, 2006]
 |
| Trade Minister David Emerson spent Thursday
defending the softwood lumber deal during a teleconference
with reporters. |
OTTAWA —
The federal government signalled Thursday it was pushing ahead with
the softwood lumber deal with the U.S. even if they do not have
broad support from the Canadian lumber
industry.
In teleconference with reporters Trade Minister David Emerson
said that a threshold in the deal that requires the support of
companies representing 95 per cent of duties deposited with the
Americans does not have to be met.
"This agreement will go to Parliament," Emerson said. "The 95 per cent
(threshold) does not represent a hard and fast veto. We do not intend to hand out a veto of that kind. We will be going forward and this agreement will have to be decided on by this Parliament."
Emerson's comments were the strongest yet against an industry he was
once a member of as an executive with lumber giant Canfor.
The deal originally had the broad support of major lumber producing
provinces and the industry when the framework was announced in
April.
But the final legal text has created divisions within the Canadian
industry, with a number of companies, provinces and lumber
associations now saying they do not support the deal, which Emerson
recently initialled with the U.S.
Emerson reiterated again on Thursday that now the deal has been
initialled between the two governments it cannot be reopened for
negotiations, as some in the industry have asked.
"This negotiation is over," Emerson said.
Prime Minister Stephen Harper said this week that legislation
to enact the deal will be a matter of confidence in Parliament,
meaning its defeat would result in an election.
Emerson has said he wants the whole process completed by October 1,
so a vote is expected shortly after MPs return from their summer
recess on September 18.
All three opposition parties appear to oppose the final wording of
the agreement and have often referred to the deal as a sell out.
That could pose a problem for the minority Conservative government,
which will need the support of at least one of the three opposition
parties to get it through the House of Commons.
Emerson's teleconference with reporters from the U.S. and Canada
came the same day the international trade committee held a rare
summer meeting on Parliament Hill.
The committee has agreed to hold sets of meetings over the summer
months.
On July 31, Emerson will appear before the committee as well as some
members of the industry.
A second meeting is scheduled for August 21.
The Conservatives submitted a list of witnesses they want to appear
before the committee, which includes Canfor, Weyerhaeuser
Corp., Abitibi-Consolidated Inc., the Quebec Forest
Industry Council, the Maritime Lumber Bureau and the Canadian
Lumber Remanufacturers Alliance.
Also on the Tory list is Frank McKenna, the former Canadian
ambassador to Washington, who was involved in softwood talks with
the U.S. for the Liberal government last year.
After the committee meeting, NDP MP Peter Julian criticized
Emerson's comments that Parliament, not the industry, will have the
final word on the deal.
"The industry is saying, 'No,'" he said. "The industry is vetoing the deal. This is becoming a really surrealist type of political approach where we know the deal is a non-starter but the government keeps pushing this and keeps saying it's going to go through regardless."
Liberal trade critic Dominic
LeBlanc accused Emerson of "changing his tune probably out
of desperation."
"This is somebody who proclaimed broad support from the
industry who now finds himself basically standing without any of the
allies he had two months ago.
"We have thought all along that Mr. Emerson and the prime
minister are going to try and bully the provinces and the industry
into supporting a bad deal and that probably just confirms (it)
again."
During his teleconference, Emerson also tried to address what he
described as "prevailing myths and misperceptions" about the
deal that have been reported in the media.
Emerson said that a controversial opt out clause contained in the
final legal text that would allow either government to get out of
the deal after 23 months is "a standard feature of international trade agreements."
© PoliticsWatch® 2006. All rights reserved. Republication
or redistribution of PoliticsWatch content, including by framing,
copying, linking or similar means, is expressly prohibited without
the prior written consent of Public Interests Research and Communications
Inc. (PIRCINC). PoliticsWatch is registered trademark of PIRCINC. |