Elections Canada stands by veil
voting [PoliticsWatch updated 1:20 p.m., September 10, 2007]
|The Conservatives, Bloc Quebecois and Liberals want
Elections Canada to reverse a decision allowing Muslim women
whose faces are covered to vote.
OTTAWA — Canada's
chief electoral officer said Monday his officials will not deny
Muslim women the right to vote if they do not show their faces at
polling stations in three federal byelections next week.
Marc Mayrand made the comments at a press conference
on Parliament Hill Monday.
He said Elections Canada officials will request Muslim women unveil
themselves, but if they refuse to do so they can still vote as long
as they present two pieces of identification and take an oath
confirming their identity.
"I have not amended the (Election) act to require them to
uncover their face," he said. "The choice continues to be
up to the individual."
Elections Canada is an independent agency that reports to
On Thursday evening, Elections Canada released a statement saying it
would allow veiled women to vote in three September 17 byelections
as long as they showed two pieces of identification or had someone
"vouch" for them at the polling station.
The statement has created a political firestorm.
Mayrand has been asked to reverse his controversial decision by
Prime Minister Stephen Harper and the leaders of the Bloc
Quebecois and the Liberals.
Harper pointed out that Mayrand's interpretation went against the
spirit of the recently passed Bill C-31, which requires voters
produce photo identification.
However, Mayrand told reporters on Monday that there is nothing in
the new voter identification law that compels visual identity of the
voters and he informed the major political parties about his plan to
allow veiled women to vote during a conference call in July. He said
there were no objections at the time.
He also used the press conference to downplay the impact of his
interpretation of the election law. Mayrand noted that there were no
requests to Elections Canada for special treatment by any group and
said that only "a few hundred" Muslim women in Canada wear
a veil for religious reasons.
"I understand that most of them would agree to lift the veil in
proper circumstances," he noted.
Relatively new to his job, the chief electoral officer now finds
himself at odds with the biggest political players in the
The Bloc is considering introducing legislation when the House
returns in October that clearly states voters must show their faces
at polling stations.
Harper has not ruled out revisiting the issue.
"So I hope that (Elections Canada) will reconsider this decision, but in the meantime if that doesn't happen, Parliament will have to consider what actions it's going to take to make sure that its intentions are put into
place," Harper said while in Australia on the weekend.
The Liberals also want Elections Canada to reconsider its
"We do believe that when they are casting a vote in
elections, Canadian citizens have a responsibility to fully reveal
their identities," Liberal leader Stéphane Dion said in
"For this reason, we would ask Elections Canada to reconsider
its decision, and to require veiled women to unveil their faces to
confirm their identity."
NDP leader Jack Layton is the only party leader not to ask
Elections Canada to reverse its decision.
Layton's office told PoliticsWatch on Friday it would
allow Elections Canada to determine how it identifies voters.
This is the second time in less than a year that veiled voting has
become controversial in Canadian politics. Earlier this year, Quebec's
provincial chief electoral officer ruled that all voters in provincial elections would have to show their faces, despite
previously deciding Muslim women could vote with a veil on.
The Canadian Coalition for Democracies was the first group to
criticize Election Canada's decision.
"Beyond the ballot box, religious face coverings have at times been misused in Canada and around the world to facilitate fraud and other criminal
acts," the group said in a statement.
"Veiling has been used abroad to advance terrorist operations, including suicide bombings. Such risks compelled France to ban the burqa in certain public spheres, and the Netherlands’ government - among others - is considering doing the same."
The group noted that "some of Canada’s elites" are
unfazed by these threats and "appear helpless in the face of radical lobbying in the name of
© PoliticsWatch® 2007. All rights reserved. Republication
or redistribution of PoliticsWatch content, including by framing,
copying, linking or similar means, is expressly prohibited without
the prior written consent of Public Interests Research and Communications
Inc. (PIRCINC). PoliticsWatch is registered trademark of PIRCINC.