Tory MP set to go down
[PoliticsWatch posted 5:15 p.m. May 9, 2006]
A backbench Conservative MP will become the first casualty of the
new Tory government on Wednesday when opposition parties will vote
no confidence in him as chair of the Aboriginal affairs committee.
Maurice Vellacott, a Saskatchewan Conservative MP first
elected to Parliament in 1997, has become the target of criticism
for the Liberals in the House of Commons for the last two days
following comments he made to a CBC reporter about Supreme Court
In that interview Vellacott said it was not the role of Supreme
Court judges to "play the position of God" and suggested
that Beverly McLachlin, the chief justice of the Supreme Court,
herself said a "mystical power" comes over judges on the
In a rare move, McLachlin through the court's executive legal
officer denied making the comments Vellacott attributed to her.
On Monday, Liberal MP Anita Neville gave notice of a motion of
non-confidence against Vellacott as chair of the Aboriginal affairs
Because the Conservatives do not have a majority of seats, the
opposition parties control the committees.
On Tuesday, all three opposition leaders said their MPs will vote
in favour of Neville's no-confidence motion, effectively removing
Vellacott as chair.
During Tuesday's question period, Interim Liberal Leader Bill
Graham demanded Prime Minister Stephen Harper ask
for Vellacott's resignation before the committee members
Harper said he would not interfere in the committee's
NDP Leader Jack Layton said Vellacott's remarks about
McLachlin were "unacceptable."
"We believe what Mr. Vellacott said requires some appropriate
action," Layton added.
Bloc Quebecois Leader Gilles Duceppe said his party's two MPs
on the committee would vote in favour of the Liberal motion.
"(Vellacott) just opened the door to be dismissed ... we'll
vote in favour of that motion."
The Tories appear resigned to the defeat of Vellacott with Harper
distancing himself and his government from the comments over the
last two days.
While Harper was willing to go to bat for floor-crossing Trade
Minister David Emerson and appointed Senator and Public Works
Minister Michael Fortier, he is not ready to fight a battle over
Vellacott's comments suggesting judicial activism on the Supreme
Court, something a number of small-c conservatives have complained
about in recent years.
Harper himself made comments about the Supreme Court in the final
days of the last election campaign when he said the Conservatives
would never have a true majority government because a Supreme Court
and public service predominantly appointed by Liberals in the past
would act as a check.
The prime minister, however, has been pointing out in the House the
hypocrisy of the Liberal complaints and to a degree media coverage
of Vellacott's comments, when similar statements have been made by
Liberal MPs in the recent past without great fanfare.
If the Liberals succeed in removing Vellacott, it will be the first
battle they have won since becoming an opposition party.
The party has been struggling in question period over the first few
weeks of the new session.
On Tuesday, Liberal MP John McCallum, the party's finance
critic, decided to attack Finance Minister Jim Flaherty for a
controversial policy idea he had when he was running to be leader of
the Ontario Progressive Conservative Party in 2002.
At the time, Flaherty proposed a plan to remove homeless people from
streets that was modelled on a successful anti-vagrancy strategy
enacted by former New York City Mayor Rudy Giuliani that
included putting street people in jail.
During his questioning, McCallum twice referred to Flaherty as an
Liberal MP Mark Holland, meanwhile, suggested in the House
that Harper's attendance at a conservative group's meeting in Kanata
over the weekend and Vellacott's comments were evidence of the
Tories' "real agenda, an agenda to destroy the independence of our
Harper rose to respond to Holland's allegations saying, "Mr. Speaker, I cannot resist answering the question about the vast right wing conspiracy.
"What I will say is that I will speak to the Minister of National Defence and see if there is any possibility in the budget of a black helicopter, so we can fly the
honourable member around to investigate his concerns."
© PoliticsWatch® 2006. All rights reserved. Republication
or redistribution of PoliticsWatch content, including by framing,
copying, linking or similar means, is expressly prohibited without
the prior written consent of Public Interests Research and Communications
Inc. (PIRCINC). PoliticsWatch is registered trademark of PIRCINC.