Volpe gives back kids' campaign
[PoliticsWatch posted 5:25 p.m. June 1, 2006]
Facing a political firestorm that was creating bad publicity for the
Liberal party leadership race, Liberal MP Joe Volpe's campaign announced
Thursday it was giving back $27,000 in campaign contributions to
five donors who are under the age of 18.
Among those donors were the 11-year-old twin children of a former
executive of the generic drug firm Apotex, the Globe and Mail
Volpe had been under fire from MPs from all parties, including
Liberals, for receiving $108,000 in donations from 20 individuals
who were either executives or former executives of Apotex or
were members of their immediate family.
Critics said accepting donations from family members of corporate
executives was a way to get around a ban on corporate donations.
Individuals are allowed to give a maximum of $5,400 to a candidate,
which is the amount of each of the five donations Volpe's campaign
returned on Thursday.
Volpe's decision to hand the money back came less than 24 hours
after he gave a lengthy interview to CPAC defending the
But before the interview went to air, Volpe's campaign had already
issued a press release stating that it would take another look at
the donations and return any if they were deemed not incompliance
with election laws or the spirit of election laws.
The Globe and Mail reported that Volpe's campaign issued the press
release shortly after the Globe called to get reaction about the two
11-year-old's maximum donations.
Jim Karygiannis, a veteran Liberal MP and Volpe's campaign
manager, told the Globe on Wednesday that there was nothing wrong
with children of any age making political donations.
But by Thursday morning Volpe's campaign said it had changed its
mind and would return five donations because although they were in
compliance with election laws "the perception was not
Volpe told CBC News late Thursday that despite what his campaign
manager told the Globe, "Until yesterday, we did not know ... or at least i did not know that there was this issue of underage minors who made donations."
The Volpe controversy has brought the wrong kind of attention to the
Liberal leadership race.
The Liberals were turfed out of government in January a few months
after a judicial inquiry found the party had benefited from an
"elaborate kickback scheme" that funneled money from a
government publicity campaign in Quebec to ad firms who in turn gave
money to party organizers in Quebec.
The other political parties had a field day with the issue on
"How it was defended yesterday as perfectly legal and perfectly
honourable and today it's so terrible, it just shows you that the
Liberal party has not change its spots," said Treasury Board
President John Baird.
"You would think after the biggest corruption scandal in
Canadian history they would want to be setting a new tone and a new
direction. The bottom line is they are not."
Liberal MP John McCallum said he did not think Volpe's
accepting the donations was "a positive for the party."
"But I think it's being rectified by his returning the
money," said McCallum.
Steven MacKinnon, the national director of the Liberal party,
commended Volpe's decision to return the money, but maintained his
campaign did nothing illegal.
"Mr. Volpe's going above and beyond the law and I think that's
commendable on his part," he said.
"I think that Mr. Volpe took the measure of people's reaction
to this story and decided he was going to give an appropriate
response. It's not for me to judge that response."
NDP MP Pat Martin said Thursday he wants to amend the federal
accountability act currently before Parliament to make it harder for
children to make big donations. Baird said the government was open
to examining the proposal.
Martin is proposing amending the law to have the children's donation
deducted from the maximum amount their parents can donate.
He has also asked the Elections Commissioner to investigate
whether campaign financing rules were circumvented by Volpe's
"It's almost as if there was some collective unconscious here
that all the Apotex executives woke up one morning and all decided
to give the maximum amount of money to one leadership candidate. We
want that investigated."
Volpe is a veteran Liberal MP who was first elected to the House of
Commons in 1988.
He was never in cabinet during the Chretien years, but held the
human resources and later immigration portfolios when Paul
Martin became prime minister.
In cabinet, Volpe was involved in controversy on a couple of
Last year, the Tories went after Volpe in question period because
his public disclosure of expenditures showed he spent $138 on a
pizza for two.
He also had to apologize last spring after describing two
Conservative MPs as members of the "Conservative Clan"
when they appeared in a newspaper photo holding a poster lampooning
the Liberals as a crime family.
While most parties have controversies involving fundraising and
party memberships, the Liberals have recently been involved in some
of the most amusing ones.
In 2002, a Victoria, B.C. man started receiving invitations to
Liberal party functions and nomination meetings addressed to Gregg
Buchanan. The only Gregg to live at his house was his golden
retriever who died five years earlier.
Included in the dead dog's mail was a Christmas card from then
finance minister Paul Martin.
© PoliticsWatch® 2006. All rights reserved. Republication
or redistribution of PoliticsWatch content, including by framing,
copying, linking or similar means, is expressly prohibited without
the prior written consent of Public Interests Research and Communications
Inc. (PIRCINC). PoliticsWatch is registered trademark of PIRCINC.